[ǀ]→[ŋ]Click Loss sound change
Certainty: 3/5Commonality: 2/5Dental click to Velar nasal
[ǀ] → [ŋ] (dental click to velar nasal) is a click loss sound change documented in 1 language, e.g. Southern Fwe kù-ŋǀânk-à 'to shell groundnuts' → Northern Fwe kù-ŋânk-à (Northern Fwe).
3 sources cited · Last updated
Click loss by deletion of the front (dental) closure: the voiced nasal dental click [ŋǀ] (written ⁿǀ by Gunnink 2022) keeps only its velar back closure and surfaces as plain [ŋ]. The mechanism is phonetic (the front closure is lost, the velar kept), but Gunnink (2020, 2022) attributes the free variation in the border area to contact between the two varieties. In Fwe (Zambia/Namibia) the click-using southern (Namibian) variety has ŋǀ where the clickless northern (Zambian) variety has ŋ, and speakers in the contact zone near the border alternate freely between the two (Gunnink 2022). Gunnink, as reported in Sands & Gunnink (2019), argues this is loss in the north rather than insertion in the south: in -ŋǀùm-ùn-à 'uproot', from Proto-Bantu *-túmʊd-, regular sound change would give Fwe s, so the northern ŋ can only come from an earlier nasal click. Gunnink (2022) states that the non-click outcomes are always velar and keep the click's voicing and nasality. Sands & Gunnink (2019) report comparable click-to-velar replacement in Northern Ndebele and Namibian Yeyi.
Phonetic Effects
Click Loss, Deletion Of Front Closure, Merger
Language Examples
Related Transformations
More Bantu Shifts
Sources & References
- Sands, B. & Gunnink, H. (2019). Clicks on the fringes of the Kalahari Basin Area. In E. Clem, P. Jenks & H. Sande (Eds.), Theory and Description in African Linguistics: Selected Papers from the 47th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, 703–724. Language Science Press. https://langsci-press.org/catalog/book/192
- Gunnink, H. (2022). A Grammar of Fwe (African Language Grammars and Dictionaries 6). Language Science Press. https://langsci-press.org/catalog/book/351
- Gunnink, H. (2020). Click loss and click insertion in Fwe. In B. Sands (Ed.), Click Consonants, 156–178. Brill (cited in Gunnink 2022).
Spotted a mistake or have a better example?
EchoDrift is community-driven. You can suggest a change directly through GitHub.
Propose an Edit on GitHub